The Owen Sound Attack have had a very successful history of receiving accolades at both the Ontario Hockey League and Canadian Hockey League level. Below is a breakdown of those players who have been recognized for their outstanding play at both of these levels.
Ontario Hockey League Award Winners
| PLAYER/STAFF | SEASON | AWARD |
| Andrew Brunette | 1992-93 | Eddie Powers Memorial Trophy |
| Jamie Storr | 1993-94 | Jim Rutherford Trophy |
| Mike Futa | 2004-05 | OHL Executive of the Year |
| Mike Angelidis | 2005-06 | Dan Snyder Award |
| Andrej Sekera | 2005-06 | Max Kaminsky Award |
| Andrew Shorkey | 2006-07 | Ivan Tennant Memorial Award |
| Mark Reeds | 2010-11 | OHL Coach of the Year |
| Dale DeGray | 2010-11 | OHL Executive of the Year |
| Robby Mignardi | 2011 | Wayne Gretzky ’99’ Award |
| Jordan Binnington | 2012-13 | Jum Rutherford Torphy |
| Jordan Binnington | 2012-13 | Dave Pinkney Trophy |
| Brandon Hope | 2012-13 | Dave Pinkney Trophy |
| Ray McKelvie | 2013 | Bill Long Award |
| Michale McNiven | 2014-15 | FW Dinty Moore Award |
| Michael McNiven | 2016-17 | Jim Rutherford Trophy |
| Michael McNiven | 2016-17 | Dave Pinkney Trophy |
| Emmanuel Vella | 2016-17 | Dave Pinkney Trophy |
| Ryan McGill | 2016-17 | Matt Leyden Trophy |
| Nick Suzuki | 2016-17 | William Hanley Trophy |
| Nick Suzuki | 2017-18 | William Hanley Trophy |
| Mack Guzda | 2017-18 | Ivan Tennant Memorial Trophy |
| Mack Guzda | 2017-18 | Ivan Tennant Memorial Trophy |
| Logan LeSage | 2018-19 | Ivan Tennant Memorial Trophy |
| Cal Uens | 2021-22 | Ivan Tennant Memorial Trophy |
| Mark Woolley | 2021-22 | Dan Snyder Memorial Trophy |
| Mark Woolley | 2021-22 | Mickey Renaud Captain’s Trophy |
| Colby Barlow | 2022-23 | Bobby Smith Trophy |
| Carter George | 2023-24 | Bobby Smith Trophy |
| Carter George | 2023-24 | Ivan Tennant Memorial Trophy |
Canadian Hockey League Award Winners
| PLAYER/STAFF | SEASON | AWARD |
| Mike Angelidis | 2005-06 | CHL Humanitarian of the Year |
| Andrew Shaw | 2011 | Memorial Cup Leading Scorer |
| Andrew Shaw | 2011 | Memorial Cup All-Star Team |
| Jordan Binnington | 2011 | Memorial Cup Outstanding Goalie |
| Jordan Binnington | 2011 | Memorial Cup All-Star Team |
| Michael McNiven | 2016-17 | CHL Goalie of the Year |
| Ryan McGill | 2016-17 | Brian Kilrea Coach of the Year |
| Nick Suzuki | 2016-17 | CHL Sportsman of the Year |
| Colby Barlow | 2022-23 | CHL Scholastic Player of the Year |
